Skip to content Skip to main menu Site Map spider trap - don't go here
. . . . .
Site Map   
The FSI home page
Grosvenor Cottage
30 Grosvenor Street, Neutral Bay
Sydney, NSW 2089 Australia
Ph: 02 9904 5600
Fax: 02 9904 5611
Coming to grips with family systems theory in a collaborative, learning environment.
Note that we are currently on the move to a new site http://www.familysystemstraining.com.
Menu items ** marked with asterisks ** will redirect you our new site.

Thanks for your patience during this time.
Home > ... > Illustration and Critique > The Theory > 7 - Sibling Positions
 

7 - Sibling Positions

Employing Walter Toman's (1976) sibling profiles, Bowen considered that sibling position could provide useful information in understanding the roles individuals tend to take in relationships.
For example, Toman's profiles describe eldest children as more likely to take on responsibility and leadership, with younger siblings more comfortable being dependent and allowing others to make decisions.  Middle children are described as having more flexibility to shift between responsibility and dependence and 'only' children are seen as being responsible, and having greater access to the adult world.
Bowen noted that these generalised traits are not universally applicable and that it is possible for a younger sibling to become the 'functional eldest'.
Bowen was especially interested in which sibling position in a family is most vulnerable to triangling with parents.  It may be that a parent identifies strongly with a child in the same sibling position as their own, or that a previous cross generational triangle (eg. an eldest child aligned with a grandparent against a parent) may be repeated.  If one sibling in the previous generation suffered a serious illness or died, it is more likely that the child of the present generation in the same sibling position will be viewed as more vulnerable and therefore more likely to detour tensions from the parental dyad.
Helping the client understand and think beyond the limitations of their own sibling position and role is a goal of Bowenian family of origin work.
Clients are encouraged to consider how assumptions about relationships are fuelled by their sibling role experience.
As with other aspects of Bowen's theory, the impact of gender and ethnicity on sibling role is not considered.  For example, there is no exploration of how a family's ethnicity influences which birth order position and which gender is more valued, or how the gender of any sibling position tends to influence whether the role is primarily relational (female), or task oriented (male).
 
previous page symbol 6 - Multi-generational Transmission Processtable of contents symbol
Table of Contents
The Model In Clinical Practice next page symbol
This paper was written by Jenny Brown and was originally published in the Australian and New Zealand Journal of Family Therapy (ANZJFT, 1999, Vol.20, No.2, pp 94-103).
The full paper is available as a pdf (221K - 10 pages - 2 columns per page).
Please contact us if you would like a printed copy sent in the post.
 
The Family Systems Institute
30 Grosvenor Street, Neutral Bay
Sydney, NSW, 2089
ABN: 49 082 618 808
Ph: 02 9904 5600
Fax: 02 9904 5611
To contact The FSI or subscribe to our newsletter (issue 3 or 4 times per year) please email or phone us
email of the fsi - please phone +61 2 9904 5600
Construction and management by
bpresent
.
.